The 4 unique challenges of healthcare fundraising—and how to overcome them

Navigating healthcare fundraising often feels like running a marathon with a backpack full of bricks—compliance requirements, stakeholder complexity, and legacy systems weigh you down at every turn. However, by addressing these common challenges strategically, healthcare fundraising teams can significantly boost efficiency, build stronger donor relationships, and ultimately increase contributions. According to the Association for Healthcare Philanthropy, for every $1 invested in fundraising, hospitals see an average return of $4.29 in the United States—that is more than a 300% return on investment. By tackling these obstacles head on, you can transform your fundraising operations into a high-performing engine that delivers exceptional results. 

1. Data privacy & compliance: Navigating HIPAA and PHI in donor engagement

Fundraising in healthcare means operating within strict regulatory frameworks like HIPAA. Protected Health Information (PHI) is tightly controlled, making donor outreach a potential compliance minefield. Any misstep in handling sensitive information can lead to serious reputational damage and legal consequences. According to IBM’s Cost of a Data Breach Report 2023, the average cost of a healthcare data breach is approximately $10.9 million per incident—the highest across all industries.

How to overcome it:

• Implement a HIPAA-compliant CRM system. Non-compliance risks legal violations and data breaches. Ensure your system includes encryption, restricted access controls, and comprehensive audit trails to protect donor trust.
• Segment donor lists responsibly by using de-identified data and opt-in consent mechanisms. Group donors by engagement level, past giving behaviors, and event participation rather than health conditions.
• Establish strict role-based access protocols so only authorized fundraising staff can interact with donor data. Configure automated permissions aligned with privacy regulations to prevent unauthorized access.

2. Complex decision-making and stakeholder coordination

Unlike traditional nonprofit fundraising, hospital networks involve multiple stakeholders—from hospital executives and foundation boards to compliance teams. This complexity often creates decision-making bottlenecks and delays campaign approvals.

How to overcome it:

• Develop comprehensive stakeholder maps to clarify who influences donation approvals. Identify champions within the hospital system who can advocate for fundraising initiatives
• Leverage data-driven reporting to make compelling cases for support. Implement dashboards that directly connect fundraising impact to patient care improvements and hospital needs
• Streamline approval workflows with automated reminders and clear deadlines. Establish a structured cadence for campaign reviews to maintain momentum for initiatives

3. Engaging grateful patients ethically

Grateful Patient Programs (GPPs) represent a crucial component of healthcare fundraising, but they require careful management. Research from the Advisory Board shows that grateful patient programs can generate up to 30% of a hospital’s annual fundraising revenue. Ethical considerations, privacy regulations, and patient trust all factor into ensuring outreach is both effective and respectful.

How to overcome it:

• Implement explicit opt-in mechanisms to ensure patients willingly participate. Allow them to specify preferred communication channels and desired engagement levels.
• Personalize outreach with discretion by focusing on impact stories rather than medical history. Connect patients with hospital initiatives that align with their experiences. 
• Provide comprehensive staff training on ethical donor engagement to ensure all interactions remain sensitive, respectful, and compliant with hospital policies.

4. Integration challenges with legacy systems

Many healthcare fundraising teams continue operating on outdated systems, resulting in inefficiencies and data silos. While transitioning to a modern CRM may seem daunting, the long-term benefits substantially outweigh the short-term disruption. A 2022 Digital Fundraising Benchmark Report for Hospitals highlights how upgrading to modern, integrated CRM systems are seeing significant improvements in donor retention compared to those relying on legacy systems—often cited as around a 27% increase.

How to overcome it:

• Select a CRM that integrates seamlessly with hospital systems to ensure real-time data synchronization across departments. Look for platforms supporting bi-directional data sharing with EMRs and financial systems.
• Implement a phased data migration strategy by prioritizing high-value donor records and gradually transitioning legacy data.
• Adopt automation for donor stewardship to improve efficiency. Configure triggered communications for acknowledgments, recurring gift reminders, and impact updates.

Best practices to elevate your fundraising strategy 

To maximize fundraising success, consider these tried-and-true best practices: 

• Leverage data-driven personalization: Tailor donor outreach based on giving history and preferences 
• Embrace multi-channel engagement: Email, social media, and events all play a role in reaching donors effectively
• Optimize for conversions: Reduce friction on donation pages with clear calls-to-action and a seamless user experience
• Build thought leadership: Publish research-backed insights and impact stories to enhance credibility
• Test & iterate: A/B test messaging, visuals, and engagement strategies to optimize performance

How Kindsight’s ascend solves these challenges

Kindsight’s ascend is a nonprofit CRM & Donor Management Software (DMS) built specifically for healthcare fundraising teams, providing:

• HIPAA-compliant donor engagement: Securely manage donor data with robust compliance safeguards
• Integrated dashboards & reporting: Access customizable, real-time analytics dashboards for comprehensive donor and fundraising data
• Streamlined stakeholder coordination: Track interactions and manage decision-making workflows efficiently
• Ethical grateful patient engagement: Implement tools ensuring transparency and respectful outreach
• Seamless Salesforce integration: Transition beyond legacy systems with a CRM designed for modern fundraising requirements

With the right technology infrastructure, healthcare fundraising teams can navigate their unique challenges more effectively, fostering donor trust, improving operational efficiency, and ultimately driving greater impact for their organizations.

Ready to transform your fundraising efforts? Learn more about Kindsight’s ascend CRM today.

---

Laura Curk

Laura (LC) is the Director of Product Marketing at Kindsight, where she makes sure Kindsight's technology is accessible and actionable. She is passionate about giving nonprofit professionals the right tools to achieve their missions and maximize their impact.